Misplaced in the Media

Blog Posts

Who am I? I found it difficult to ask myself such a simple question as most young adults are unsure of how to identify themselves. Clearly, I am an eighteen year old female, but that is merely the surface of who I am. While some aspects of my identity are represented in the media, others are not. Significant aspects of my identity are misplaced in media. I find it difficult to assess whether or not I feel represented as an individual in media and news because I have found my identity is unique from others.

To most people, I appear to be fully white; however that is not my ethnicity, I am also half Cuban. My father moved to the United States from Cuba when he was very young, was a first generation college student, and worked very hard to be where he is today. I am very proud of my ethnicity and it shapes my identity. When I tell others that I am Cuban it comes as a shock to them because I “don’t look Cuban enough.” It is frustrating when such an important aspect of my identity is disregarded or questioned because I don’t fit the cookie cutter mold that people expect. This cookie cutter mold is shaped and cultivated by the limited representation of Cuban people in news and media.

I am half white and that part of me is always represented in the media. I am also half Cuban but that part of my identity is rarely represented in the media. How do I decide whether I feel represented or not when half of my identity is always represented and the other half is not? As I grapple with how to answer this question, I have thought about whether I identify more as white or Cuban. I can not reach a conclusion because I shouldn’t have to choose just one part of my identity. I am uniquely me and should never need to decide between the different parts of my background. I do recognize that the white part of my background has always been more represented in American media. I also recognize that there is not enough representation of my Cuban background. I am proud of my identity as a woman who is both white and Cuban, I will never see one part of my background as more important because both make me the person I am today.

The juxtaposition of my identity was reflected in a Los Angeles Times article  by Tre’vell Anderson. According to Anderson, “White women gained some ground in film criticism… But other marginalized groups — particularly men and women of color — struggled to gain any access.” I feel torn because most people see me as a white woman, which grants me more opportunities; however I am proud to be Cuban and want to represent women of color. Society categorizes people and does not give us an opportunity to explain who we truly are or what makes up our identity. As someone who is white and Cuban, I don’t ever want to be categorized as one or the other. My race and ethnicity make me who I am and give me a unique perspective that I want to express. My identity is partly represented in media and news, so it is hard to find authentic representations of my entire identity. Media and news should consult more diverse perspectives from people of color. All people should be given a voice and have representation in media and news.

The other part of my identity, which is very important to me, is that I am a woman. As a woman studying journalism, I have noticed that the majority of journalists and editors are men. I don’t feel that enough women are represented or recognized as journalists, despite the fact that so many women pursue an education in journalism and have the same credentials as men. I aspire to be a journalist and hope that one day more women will be appreciated for their unique perspectives in journalism. There needs to be more female representation and perspectives in the newsroom. The women who are currently recognized in the newsroom are very authentic and I feel as though I can identify with those women. The future is female and I aspire to be a part of that future in the newsroom.

Nice Nails, Nice Coverage

Blog Posts

The New York Times published an exposé by Sarah Maslin Nir called The Price of Nice Nails. Nir tackled the unaddressed issue of underpaid employees in the nail industry, by directly interviewing exploited workers who are not typically given a voice. I conducted the SMELL Test to assess the credibility of Nir’s article.

The source can be attributed to The New York Times because they published the exposition and the journalist who wrote it was Sarah Maslin Nir. Originally a freelance journalist in London for national and international publications, Nir has been a staff reporter at The New York Times since 2011. In assessing the credibility of the source, Nir, I utilized the PIE Test. Nir had no direct connections to the nail salon industry she was reporting on, so her proximity was far enough away. Free from conflict of interest, Nir has no conflicts that would interfere with her report and independence. Nir’s lived experience in the field of journalism covered a wide range of topics from breaking news to night life in New York; therefore, Nir has a wide range of expertise as a journalist. Considering the PIE Test, I have determined Sarah Maslin Nir to be a credible source.

The motive for Nir writing the exposé was to shed light on the exploitation of laborers in the nail industry. Nir conducted the investigation for an entire year, devoting her work to uncovering the truth about the exploitation of laborers in the nail industry. Nir’s motivation was uncovering the truth which was a selfless act since she personally had nothing to gain from the exposé. The purpose of the message was to reveal the truth about New York City’s nail industry.

The evidence of the exploitation is in the form of quotes from employees obtained in interviews. “The New York Times interviewed more than 150 nail salon workers and owners, in four languages,” to compile evidence. The quotes are attributed to people who work in the nail industry and the hardships they have endured due to the unjust working conditions. Additionally, the evidence is drawn from other sources about minimum wage and court cases in regards to the nail industry’s exploitative labor practices. The evidence provided was collected over the course of an entire year, which displays Nir’s attention to detail and commitment to uncovering the truth.

The information collected and reported by Nir is logical and makes sense because she provides sufficient evidence. All of the quotes and personal stories from those who work in the nail industry contribute to the logical flow of Nir’s exposé. The angle through which Nir covered the story made it logical and easy for the reader to comprehend. The evidence is a key factor because it all supports Nir’s conclusions about the nail industry and logically explains the injustices laborers face.

After conducting further research about the nail industry I could not find anything that Nir left out of her report. Nir even went on to write about the health hazards of the nail salon industry to elaborate on her argument that nail salon workers face horrible conditions. The interviews Nir conducted ensured she did not leave anything out as she interviewed both the workers and owners of nail salons to hear multiple sides of the story. Nir conducted extensive research and interviews to ensure she was not leaving anything out of her report.

Sarah Maslin Nir collected extensive evidence from minorities who are typically underrepresented. The year long investigation was thoroughly conducted and carefully researched to make an informed conclusion about the nail industry. Based on my findings, The New York Times article The Price of Nice Nails is very credible. Sarah Maslin Nir and The New York Times published a detailed, hard hitting exposé that revealed the truth about New York City’s nail industry.

Meaningful Media

Blog Posts

It’s no surprise that media consumption has increased as people log into their Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram on daily basis. Media is a significant aspect of our everyday lives whether we are sharing memes with our friends or reading a news post on Twitter.

While recording my personal media consumption habits I came to question if the media I am consuming is meaningful; by “meaningful” I am referring to content that’s significant to myself and others. Whether media is considered meaningful depends on the user and the audience the user engages with. For instance, when I send my friends a photo as I walk to class on Snapchat I am updating them on my day. While my subpar photograph is not significant to the entire world, the “audience” I am sharing it with engages with the content; so I consider it meaningful media.

I found on a daily basis I consume most of my media from specific apps including Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, the iPhone News App, and Spotify. I concluded I tend to use the more social applications, such as Instagram, Spotify and Snapchat, when I am sharing media content with friends. Alternatively, when I use applications like the iPhone News App and Twitter I tend to look for more news articles and publications of interest to me.

On Instagram and Snapchat I am able to share content and media that is meaningful to the people I communicate with in my everyday life. According to the Pew Research Center, “a majority of Snapchat (63%) and Instagram (60%) users indicate that they visit these platforms on a daily basis.” http://www.pewinternet.org/2018/03/01/social-media-use-in-2018/ I noted that I engaged with these social media platforms multiple times throughout the day because communicating and connecting with others is meaningful to me. Whether I am commenting on my friends post about their latest achievement or just sending a funny photo, I am engaging and sharing media that is meaningful to my “audience” and myself.

When I consume media on the iPhone News App, I tend to consume informative content. For example, when I refreshed the iPhone News App I first read an article from the New York Times about the effects of the government shutdown. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/18/business/economy/government-shutdown-polls-economy.html  The news I consume is meaningful media because it is informative and significant to many people. However, I did take note that that the articles I engaged with were all of personal interest to me. This is consequential because I should be consuming multiple articles to be an informed citizen and have conversations about significant issues.

Overall, media consumption habits have positive and negative effects depending on the user’s daily interaction with certain platforms. Media is so powerful because we always have content right at our fingertips. We have to take advantage of the opportunity to consume meaningful media and share it with others to positively contribute to the media landscape.